• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream: Authentic Caribbean Flavors & Unique Vegan Options in Brooklyn

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream in Brooklyn is a vibrant gem offering an exceptional range of Caribbean-inspired flavors crafted with quality, love, and creativity. Renowned for its unique selections like soursop, sorrel, and mauby tree bark, this spot delights with creamy, refreshing textures and authentic tropical undertones. Customers praise the shop's welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff, highlighting standout flavors such as soursop cherry and ginger specials. Vegan and dairy-free options add to its inclusive appeal. Each scoop captures the essence of homemade joy, making Mr P's a must-visit for adventurous ice cream lovers seeking bold, refreshing, and memorable tastes.

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream at a glance

  • Address 1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226, United States
  • Phone +1 973-640-3200
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream: Reviews & Ratings

Amanda Wang
4

Today we tried ice cream from here. Homemade is real, consistency of the ice cream looks like sorbet, but omg the soursop flavor? yummy. Creamy and lychee undertone real soursop. Cant wait to go back and try more. Avocado tho? eh, cause it tasted too sweet and not thick enough for me. Sea moss was also kinda soapy tasting idk thats our opinion tho. It smells so good inside the cakes they have? I really wanted some, it was so tempting. But highly, strongly, and encourage u to get soursop flavor if you love soursop.

Paulina Armstrong
5

Updated review 8/14/24: Mr. P’s is still here serving the most delicious homemade ice creams with so many flavors to choose from. Today, I decided to get the soursop cherry ice cream in a cup and boy oh boy, I’m happy with my choice. It is extremely refreshing and delicious. 09/7/23 I stopped by to try a scoop of soursop ice cream. It was sweet but delicious. They have so many unique and different flavors. I’m excited to visit again to try out the other flavors. The decor is very colorful and nice.

Penney Jade Beaubrun
5

Mr. P’s Homemade Ice cream is EXCEPTIONAL! The place is clean, the ice cream delicious and the staff very friendly. Kenton took great care of us! He was patient, accommodating and filled my cup to the brim. My cousin and I even snapped a picture with Mr. P! It was my first time there but it won’t be my last. I am one happy girl!

Ophelia Smith
5

Had the pleasure of having the sorrel, chocolate, mango and coconut ice cream. The sorrel was the best. Plan on going back to get other flavors

Anna H
5

The best icecream in NYC. Quality ingredients. Made with love. So many different carribean flavors. Shout out to Dwuane for explaining everything to us and being so kind. The icecream is perfectly sweet. Nice custard. I give this place 10 star. Vegan and Dairy free options with icecream and cakes and shakes. The peanut and banana were my favorite. The ginger flavors outrageous. The mauby tree bark so unique and delicious . Guava and grape nuts great. Charcoal was fun. The elderberry and ginget special was outrageous. Beautiful inside. Well be back. Top notch.

CL G
5

The man that runs this shop opened on time. I put some money in the meter and walked in. He sells flavors that are not common to find. He gives you 3 tastes of ice creams. I ordered the cherry soursop. He sells grape nut, which is hard to find. I tasted the peanut flavor ice cream and it tasted spot on. He fills the ice cream tubs to the brim. I did not see cones when I walked in. I'll have to ask if he carries them. He also makes milk shakes. Maybe one day, I'll try that.

arnold adrian
4

Amazing ice cream… my favorite are the grape nut and soursop. Also their carrot cake is absolutely delicious. Good place to get your homemade ice cream and cakes

Alan Varghese
5

Brilliant flavorful Caribbean inspired ice cream many unique (charcoal, seamoss etc) and some classical flavors (20 ish total with 10 vegan), large portions (3 scoops was nearly a pint), good prices ($3 per scoop), some indoor seating and they allow sampling. Definitely recommend. My favorite flavors were the sorrel ginger (a lovely warming spice with some tartness that while chilled is just something else. One of the best sorbets I have ever had) and charcoal (not very smoky but a brilliant black). The chocolate and vanilla were also quite good. Will comeback to have more.

Location

  • Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream
    Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream
    1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226, United States Hotline: +1 973-640-3200

Nestled in Brooklyn’s vibrant neighborhood at 1397 Nostrand Ave, Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream offers a refreshing dive into uniquely crafted, Caribbean-inspired frozen delights. This ice cream shop stands out not just for its inviting ambiance but for its carefully curated menu that plays with bold, authentic flavors you rarely find elsewhere.

At the heart of their offerings is the much-loved Soursop Ice Cream, celebrated by many patrons for its creamy texture and delicate lychee undertones. The soursop flavor delivers a bright, tropical freshness that feels both nostalgic and novel—perfectly balanced sweetness and a rich custard base make it irresistibly refreshing. The Soursop and Grapenut Ice Cream and the Ginger Beet Soursop and Seamoss Ice Cream Cone showcase how Mr P's artfully blends textures and exotic ingredients, offering an adventurous twist beyond typical parlor fare.

Equally compelling is their 3 Flavor Ice Cream Cone, allowing you to sample the medley of creative offerings—each scoop telling its own story. The Pistachio Ice Cream delivers a creamy, nutty depth, while the Affogato provides a sharp espresso contrast, appealing to those who crave a robust finish.

Mr P’s also impresses with their sorbet selections and inventive milkshakes, especially the Soursop Milkshake that captures the essence of the fruit with a smooth, luscious consistency. While some flavors, like avocado and sea moss, evoke mixed reactions—showcasing the bold experimentation that defines the brand—the overall commitment to quality, local ingredients, and authentic craft shines through.

What truly elevates the experience is the genuine warmth of the staff and the clear passion behind every batch. Visits here feel like stepping into a welcoming, colorful haven where Caribbean heritage and homemade goodness meet. Whether you’re craving classic richness or exotic, daring tastes like mauby tree bark or elderberry ginger, Mr P’s Homemade Ice Cream invites you to explore, savor, and delight in an exceptional range of ice cream and sweet treats made with love.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway